General News

GES Code of Conduct Under Fire Over Dismissal Sanctions for Student Sexual Offences

Published

on

The Ghana Education Service (GES) has been urged to review portions of its 2024 Harmonised Code of Conduct for Students in Pre-Tertiary Schools following concerns that the disciplinary measures prescribed for sexual offences are disproportionate, discriminatory and potentially harmful to students’ educational futures.

Seth Afum A. Dankwah of J. G. Knol Technical Institute in Adukrom-Akuapem, Eastern Region, has raised serious concerns about Section 2.16 of the Code, arguing that it fails to distinguish between minor misconduct and serious sexual crimes when prescribing disciplinary sanctions.

In a detailed legal analysis titled “A Critical Analysis of the Non-Graduated Sanctions for Sexual Offences Under Section 2.16 (a–k),” Dankwah questioned the fairness of applying dismissal as the listed disciplinary sanction to offences ranging from students meeting in obscure places at odd hours to rape.

According to him, the existing provisions place school authorities and disciplinary committees in a difficult position, where strictly enforcing the Code could result in unfair punishment, while exercising discretion could mean departing from the prescribed guidelines.

“Follow the Code and be unjust, or be just and break the Code,” he stated.

The GES introduced the Harmonised Code of Conduct through a circular dated January 4, 2024, to guide discipline and promote consistent standards across pre-tertiary educational institutions.

However, Dankwah argues that Section 2.16, which contains eleven provisions covering sexual misconduct and related matters, lacks an appropriate system for determining punishment based on the seriousness of an offence.

The provisions address sexual relations between students, interactions in obscure places at odd times, sexual harassment, failure to report or prevent sexual offences, pregnancy and re-entry support, rape, sexual relations involving school staff, forced sexual contact, preventing students from returning home, and same-sex sexual conduct.

Under the sanctions outlined on page 19 of the Code, the disciplinary measures listed include reporting cases to the police depending on their gravity while disciplinary proceedings are instituted, and dismissal.

Dankwah maintains that this arrangement fails to provide sufficient flexibility for disciplinary committees to consider the circumstances surrounding individual cases.

He explained that other sections of the Code provide a range of disciplinary options, including caution, counselling, manual work, internal suspension, external suspension, bonds, withdrawal from boarding facilities and dismissal for repeated misconduct.

According to him, the absence of similar graduated sanctions under Section 2.16 creates an unfair disciplinary structure.

For instance, he questioned why a student found interacting with another student in an obscure location at an inappropriate time should face the same listed dismissal sanction as a student found guilty of rape.

He also cited Section 2.16(j), which concerns preventing another student from returning home during vacation or when the student wishes to leave, as another example of conduct requiring individual assessment.

Dankwah argued that school disciplinary measures must reflect the seriousness of the offence rather than treating all violations as equally severe.

A major part of Dankwah’s criticism focuses on Section 2.16(e), which provides for the application of the GES guideline on preventing pregnancy among schoolgirls and facilitating their re-entry into school after childbirth.

While acknowledging the importance of protecting pregnant students and ensuring their continued education, he argued that the provision does not offer equivalent support to other students involved in consensual sexual activity.

According to him, a girl who becomes pregnant after consensual sexual relations may benefit from the re-entry arrangement, while the boy involved in the same act may still face dismissal under Section 2.16(a).

He further questioned the treatment of a girl who engages in consensual sexual activity but does not become pregnant.

Dankwah argued that such a student may not qualify for the pregnancy-related protection despite engaging in the same conduct as a student who becomes pregnant.

He described the situation as unequal treatment arising from the consequences of sexual activity rather than the conduct itself.

“The act was joint, but the consequence is not,” he argued, stressing that disciplinary measures should not protect one student while exposing another to potentially severe punishment for the same consensual conduct.

He maintained that although pregnant students require additional medical, emotional and educational support, the wider disciplinary framework should provide counselling and appropriate safeguards for all students, irrespective of sex or pregnancy outcome.

Dankwah also questioned whether the provisions meet Ghana’s constitutional and child protection standards.

He cited Article 17 of the 1992 Constitution, which prohibits discrimination on specified grounds, including gender, and Article 23, which requires administrative bodies and officials to act fairly and reasonably.

He further referred to Article 28 of the Constitution, which addresses children’s rights and protection.

His analysis also drew on the Children’s Act, 1998 (Act 560), particularly the requirement that the best interests of the child must be paramount in matters affecting children.

Additionally, he referenced Ghana’s obligations under the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child and the African Charter on the Rights and Welfare of the Child.

Dankwah argued that disciplinary decisions affecting students should take account of their age, emotional development, circumstances and educational needs.

He acknowledged that the GES Code is an administrative instrument rather than an Act of Parliament but maintained that decisions made under it must still satisfy applicable standards of fairness and reasonableness.

His article contends that the absence of clearly defined disciplinary alternatives could expose school authorities to legal challenges where sanctions are considered excessive or arbitrary.

These are legal arguments advanced by Dankwah; the analysis does not establish that a court has declared Section 2.16 unconstitutional.

Dankwah stressed that his criticism should not be interpreted as opposition to disciplinary action against students who commit sexual offences.

He maintained that serious crimes, particularly rape, require firm institutional action, police involvement and appropriate protection for victims.

However, he argued that minor or non-violent misconduct should not automatically attract the most severe disciplinary sanction.

According to him, disciplinary committees should be permitted to consider factors such as the student’s age, intention, level of harm, previous misconduct, remorse and the circumstances surrounding the incident.

He suggested that dismissing students for relatively minor offences could undermine the educational and corrective purposes of school discipline.

He also warned that severe sanctions without appropriate alternatives could discourage victims and witnesses from reporting certain forms of misconduct.

For example, he argued that students might hesitate to report harassment if they believe the only possible disciplinary outcome would be the dismissal of a classmate.

He suggested that some school authorities could equally become reluctant to take action where the prescribed punishment appears excessive.

To address the concerns, Dankwah proposed a graduated disciplinary framework that would classify offences according to their seriousness.

His recommendations include:

Proposed category Relevant provisions Recommended disciplinary measures
Tier 1: Minor or non-contact offences 2.16(b), (d), (j) Caution, counselling, parental involvement and bond
Tier 2: Harassment and consensual sexual relations 2.16(a), (c) Counselling, internal suspension of up to two weeks, bond and referral to the Guidance and Counselling Unit
Tier 3: Forcible contact, exploitation and same-sex conduct 2.16(i), (h), (k) External suspension pending investigation, disciplinary proceedings, victim support and dismissal for persistence or serious harm
Tier 4: Grave or criminal offences 2.16(g), rape Immediate suspension pending investigation, mandatory police and education authority referral, victim support and dismissal if proved

Under his proposed arrangement, students found responsible for first-time offences within the first two categories would not face dismissal.

He argued that the approach would allow schools to maintain discipline while ensuring that punishment remains proportionate to the seriousness of the misconduct.

However, the proposed categories would require further legal and safeguarding review, particularly regarding staff-student sexual relations, non-consensual conduct, the treatment of same-sex conduct and circumstances requiring mandatory reporting to law enforcement.

Dankwah also proposed an amendment to Section 2.16(e) to expand the availability of counselling and support services.

He recommended that the provision should read:

“The GES Guideline for prevention of pregnancy and facilitation of Re-Entry, and counselling and support services, shall be applied to all students involved in sexual conduct, irrespective of sex or pregnancy outcome, with additional health and educational support for the pregnant girl.”

He explained that this would preserve the additional protection available to pregnant students while extending appropriate counselling and educational support to other affected students.

According to him, the objective should be to ensure that child protection measures do not create unnecessary differences in the treatment of students.

“Protection must generally follow the child, not just the pregnant,” he stated.

Beyond the classification of offences, Dankwah called for stronger procedural safeguards to ensure fairness in school disciplinary proceedings.

He proposed that disciplinary decisions should be documented in writing, with clear explanations of the circumstances considered before sanctions are imposed.

He also recommended that students should have access to an appeals process involving the District Director of Education, Regional Director and GES Council.

Furthermore, he called for mandatory victim protection measures, including counselling, protection against retaliation and relocation where necessary and appropriate.

He maintained that these measures would strengthen confidence in school disciplinary systems while protecting the rights and welfare of students.

Dankwah warned that maintaining a disciplinary system without clearly graduated sanctions could place school heads and disciplinary committees in a difficult position.

He argued that officials may either apply the listed sanctions strictly, even when they appear excessive, or introduce alternative disciplinary measures not expressly provided for under the relevant section.

According to him, such uncertainty could undermine the harmonisation objective of the Code and lead to inconsistent disciplinary decisions across schools.

He maintained that dismissal should be reserved for offences serious enough to justify ending a student’s enrolment at a particular institution, rather than being treated as the standard punishment for all sexual misconduct.

“GES harmonised the offences. It must now harmonise justice/sanctions,” he stated.

He further argued that disciplinary systems should not sacrifice students’ educational opportunities when less severe corrective measures could adequately address misconduct.

“No child — boy or girl, pregnant or not — should have his or her education ended by a table that cannot tell the difference between a conversation and a crime,” he concluded.

The analysis, authored by Seth Afum A. Dankwah of J. G. Knol Technical Institute, Adukrom-Akuapem, Eastern Region, calls for a comprehensive review of Section 2.16 to ensure that disciplinary sanctions are proportionate, legally sound and consistent with the best interests of children.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending

Exit mobile version